Antarctic Star 12 Bottle 48 Can Wine Cooler Review
This is a small, simple compressor fridge that does two jobs reasonably well, as long as you accept one zone, occasional defrosting and a listing that leaves several questions unanswered.
Updated:
Wine Cooler Types: How to Choose the Right Kind
Disclosure This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Wine Cellar Diva earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
The Essentials
Every wine cooler is defined by four choices: how it cools (compressor or thermoelectric), how many temperature zones it has (one or two), where it goes (built in, under a counter, freestanding or on a countertop) and how many bottles it holds. Make the placement choice first, because a freestanding cooler cannot safely go inside cabinetry. Of the models we review, the highest rated is the Allavino VSWR172-2SR20, a compressor, dual zone, built-in tower. Each type below links to its own guide with every model we review in that group.
How These Recommendations Are Made
I have spent over ten years testing and reviewing wine coolers, wine cellar equipment, and wine-related gear, and tracking how it actually holds up over time. No unit on this page was bench-tested. These recommendations are built from manufacturer specifications, the Amazon listings’ own stated figures, owner reports and comparison against units in the same size class.
Wine Cooler Types at a Glance
| Type | What It Means | Choose It If | Top-Rated Model We Review |
|---|---|---|---|
| How it cools | |||
| Compressor | Cools like a kitchen fridge, with a compressor and refrigerant | You want the widest temperature range or more than a dozen bottles | Allavino VSWR172-2SR20 (4.5/5) |
| Thermoelectric | Cools with a solid-state module and a fan, no compressor | You want a small, quiet countertop unit in a room that stays cool | Koolatron WC20 Urban Series (4.0/5) |
| How many zones | |||
| Single zone | One temperature for the whole cabinet | Your collection is mostly one kind of wine, or kept for long-term storage | Allavino VSWR177-1SR20 (4.3/5) |
| Dual zone | Two compartments with separate settings | You keep whites and reds, or wine and drinks, at different temperatures | Allavino VSWR172-2SR20 (4.5/5) |
| Where it goes | |||
| Built-in | Vents through the front so it can sit inside cabinetry | The cooler will be enclosed by cabinets | Allavino VSWR172-2SR20 (4.5/5) |
| Under-counter | A built-in model sized to fit beneath a kitchen counter | You have a 12, 15 or 24 inch opening under a counter | Kalamera 24 Inch 46-Bottle (4.3/5) |
| Freestanding | Needs open air around it to shed heat | The cooler will stand on its own, away from cabinets | Schmecke 24 Bottle (4.2/5) |
| Countertop | Small enough to sit on a counter or table | You keep only a handful of bottles | Koolatron WC12 (3.8/5) |
| How many bottles | |||
| Mini | The smallest units we review, from 6 bottles | You want a few bottles chilled and ready | Koolatron WC06 (3.8/5) |
| Compact | Narrow units around 10 inches wide | Space is tight but you want more than a mini | Koolatron KWT10BN (3.9/5) |
| Small | Mini, compact and countertop models together | You keep a small rotating collection | NewAir Shadow Series 12 Bottle / 39 Can (4.2/5) |
| Medium | Mid-size models such as 15-inch under-counter units | You keep a few dozen bottles | Schmecke 24 Bottle (4.2/5) |
| Large | 24-inch under-counter units up to full-height towers | You keep a growing collection | Allavino VSWR172-2SR20 (4.5/5) |
| What it holds | |||
| Wine and beverage | Holds cans and drinks as well as wine | One cooler has to cover wine and drinks | NewAir Shadow Series 12 Bottle / 39 Can (4.2/5) |
Ratings are from our reviews. Each guide lists every model we review in that group.
Rating Context: Wine Cooler Types
Each model is rated against others of the same type and size, so a 3.8 countertop unit and a 3.8 tower are each judged against their own peers. Across all types, a model gains points for published specifications, front venting where it is sold for built-in use, a strong owner record and a longer warranty. It loses points for missing or conflicting specifications, a cabinet wider than its stated size or a thin owner record.
Disclosure The buttons below are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Wine Cellar Diva earns from qualifying purchases.
The Shortlist: Best Pick for Each Type
Allavino VSWR172-2SR20: Best Large Dual Zone and Built-In
A 172-bottle compressor tower with an upper zone of 40 to 55 F and a lower zone of 55 to 65 F, fan-forced circulation and front venting for a 24-inch opening. It is the highest-rated model we review. Read the review.
Affiliate link
Allavino VSWR177-1SR20: Best Single Zone
A 177-bottle compressor tower held at one temperature from 41 to 64 F, with front venting for built-in use and a keyed lock. The Amazon link goes to the left-hinge version, the one available there. Read the review.
Affiliate link
Kalamera KRC-150DZB-C3 46-Bottle: Best Under-Counter
Forty-six bottles in two zones, 40 to 50 F and 50 to 66 F, in a 33-inch tall cabinet with front venting and zero rear clearance. Buy it for a standard 24-inch opening under a kitchen counter. Read the review.
Affiliate link
Schmecke 24 Bottle: Best Freestanding
Twenty-four bottles in one compressor-cooled zone of 41 to 64 F, with automatic defrost and a listed 122.64 kWh a year. It is freestanding only, so give it open air around the cabinet. Read the review.
Affiliate link
Koolatron KWT10BN 10-Bottle: Best Thermoelectric
Ten bottles in a cabinet 9.8 inches wide, cooled by a thermoelectric module from 46 to 66 F with no compressor. It needs 5 inches of clearance on all sides. Read the review.
Affiliate link
NewAir Shadow Series 12 Bottle / 39 Can: Best Wine and Beverage
Twelve bottles plus 39 cans in two zones, each set anywhere from 37 to 64 F, behind a mirrored glass door with a lock. The listed noise rating is 35 dB. It is freestanding. Read the review.
Affiliate link
All six were in stock on Amazon when we checked on October 5, 2026.
Wine Cooler Type Mistakes to Avoid
Building in a freestanding cooler
A freestanding cooler releases heat through the back or sides. Boxed into cabinetry, it runs hot and wears out early. If the cooler will be enclosed, buy a model listed for built-in use with front venting.
Expecting a thermoelectric unit to run cold
The thermoelectric models we review bottom out at 46 F, while most compressor models reach 40 or 41 F. If you want whites or sparkling wine well chilled, choose a compressor model.
Choosing by bottle count alone
Bottle counts assume slim standard bottles, and some listings give conflicting counts. Measure the space first and check the width, height and depth with the handle included.
Expecting two fully independent zones
Many dual zone models make one zone run warmer than the other or require a set gap between them. The dual zone guide lists the range of each zone for every model we review.
The Technical Truth: How Each Type of Wine Cooler Works
Compressor or Thermoelectric
A compressor cooler works like a kitchen fridge and reaches lower temperatures: most compressor models we review go down to 40 or 41 F. A thermoelectric cooler uses a solid-state module and a fan, so it has no compressor to vibrate, but the models we review stop at 46 F and hold 20 bottles or fewer.
Built-In or Freestanding
The difference is where the heat goes. A built-in model pushes it out through a grille at the front, so the sides and back can sit against cabinetry. A freestanding model releases it through the back or sides and needs open air around it. Most built-in models can also stand on their own; a freestanding model should not be built in.
How Much Electricity Does a Wine Cooler Use?
Size and design matter more than cooling type. The Schmecke 24 Bottle, a compressor model, lists 122.64 kWh a year, while the Ivation 12 Bottle thermoelectric unit lists 150 kWh and the Koolatron WC20 thermoelectric unit 235 kWh. At the large end, Allavino’s Energy Guide label for the VSWR172-2 gives 556 kWh. At an example rate of 15 cents per kWh, that runs from about 18 to about 83 dollars a year. The energy-efficient wine fridge guide compares listed yearly use across models.
How to Care for Any Type of Wine Cooler
Keep the vents clear, front or rear depending on the type, and vacuum them a few times a year. Check that the door gasket seals all the way around. Leave the clearances the manufacturer lists, which matters most for freestanding and thermoelectric units.
Wine Cellar Space Calculator
Work out the capacity your space will actually take before you buy.
Wine Cooler Comparison Matrix
Put shortlisted models side by side on the specifications that matter.
Wine Cellar ROI Calculator
Weigh what proper storage costs against the value of the wine it protects.
Your Questions, Answered
Which type of wine fridge is better, thermoelectric or compressor?
For most buyers, compressor. It reaches lower temperatures and comes in every size, from 15-inch under-counter units to full-height towers. Thermoelectric suits a small, quiet countertop unit in a room that stays cool.
Is there a difference between a wine fridge and a wine cooler?
For appliances, no: the two names are used for the same thing, and we use both. A wine cooler is also a drink made from wine and fruit juice, which is a different product altogether.
What are the downsides of thermoelectric cooling?
The thermoelectric models we review stop at 46 F, hold 20 bottles or fewer and must stand freestanding with open air around them; the Koolatron KWT10BN asks for 5 inches of clearance on every side.
How to choose the right wine cooler?
Decide where it will go first: inside cabinetry needs a built-in model with front venting. Then choose one or two zones based on what you drink, and size it to your collection with room to grow.
Which wine fridge is the best?
Of the models we review, the Allavino VSWR172-2SR20 rates highest at 4.5 out of 5 for a large collection. For a 24-inch space under a counter, the Kalamera 24 Inch 46-Bottle rates 4.3.
Disclosure The links below are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Wine Cellar Diva earns from qualifying purchases.
The Last Word: Which Type of Wine Cooler Should You Buy?
Our Recommendation
Choose the placement first, then the zones, then the size. For most kitchens that means a built-in compressor model under the counter, and the Kalamera 46-bottle is the one to buy for a 24-inch opening.
Related Guides
→ All Wine Cooler Brands
→ Built-In Wine Coolers
→ Dual Zone Wine Coolers
→ Energy-Efficient Wine Fridges
→ Built-In Wine Coolers
→ Dual Zone Wine Coolers
→ Energy-Efficient Wine Fridges
Latest Wine Cooler Reviews
AKDY AK-WC0070 Discontinued – Best Alternatives
The AKDY AK-WC0070 20-bottle compressor cooler can no longer be bought new, so this page points you to current coolers that do the same job.
EdgeStar CWR362FD 36 Bottle Dual Zone Wine Cooler Review
The EdgeStar CWR362FD has one of the more unusual built-in dual zone layouts in this size, and I would buy it for the doors and the flexible zones rather than for bottle count or value.
Kalamera KRC-150CB Wine and Beverage Cooler Discontinued – Best Alternatives
The Kalamera KRC-150CB, the 24-inch cooler with a wine side and a can side behind French doors, has dropped off Amazon, so here is what I would buy in its place.
Allavino YHWR305-1BLT Discontinued – Best Alternatives
The Allavino YHWR305-1BLT 305 bottle cellar is no longer on sale, and three current Allavino cabinets now cover the same large-collection job.
NutriChef PKTEWC16 Discontinued – Best Alternatives
The NutriChef PKTEWC16 is no longer on sale, so here are three current coolers that cover the same small-collection job, and what each one does better or worse.